№ 03
LLC vs. S Corporation: Could an S Election Save Your Business Money?
How an S election changes an LLC owner’s taxes, and how to tell whether it fits.
Contents 8
Once an LLC is consistently profitable, its owner often hears the same suggestion: elect S corporation status and pay less tax. For business owners in Virginia, Maryland, and Washington, D.C., the LLC vs. S Corp question deserves a careful answer, because the result depends on federal, state, and individual factors.
An S election is a federal tax election. It changes how the owner’s earnings are taxed, while the LLC remains the same legal entity under state law. There is no magic profit number at which an S Corp automatically makes sense. The decision should be based on the owner’s and business’s actual numbers.
For an election that would take effect on January 1, 2027, reviewing those numbers before year-end leaves time to plan payroll and prepare the filing.
Understand the Choice
Is an LLC Taxed as an S Corp? Legal Entity vs. Tax Election
A limited liability company (LLC) is a business structure allowed by state statute. Its federal tax classification depends on how many members it has and on the elections it makes. By default, an LLC with one member is disregarded as separate from its owner for income tax purposes, so the owner generally reports the business’s income on their own return. An LLC with two or more members is generally classified as a partnership. Either can elect to be treated as a corporation.
An S election is made on Form 2553. An eligible LLC that files a timely S election is treated as a corporation for federal tax purposes from the election’s effective date, and it does not need to file a separate Form 8832.
Sources: IRS: Limited Liability Company (LLC); IRS: Instructions for Form 2553
Who Can Elect
To elect S corporation status, a business generally must:
- be a domestic corporation, or a domestic entity eligible to be treated as a corporation;
- have no more than 100 shareholders;
- have only allowable shareholders, such as individuals, certain trusts, and estates (partnerships, corporations, and nonresident aliens may not be shareholders);
- have only one class of stock; and
- not be an ineligible corporation, such as certain financial institutions and insurance companies.
All required shareholders must consent to the election on Form 2553. This generally means every shareholder at the time the election is made and, in some cases, former shareholders. For an LLC with more than one member, the one-class-of-stock requirement generally means that distributions follow ownership percentages, which can matter when an operating agreement divides profit differently.
Sources: IRS: S Corporations; IRS: Instructions for Form 2553
Before comparing numbers, confirm how your LLC is classified today and whether it can make the election.
How an S Corp Election May Save Money
Employment Taxes Without the Election
Under the default rules, the owner of a profitable single-member LLC generally pays self-employment tax in addition to income tax. Self-employment tax consists of 12.4% for Social Security and 2.9% for Medicare, and it generally applies to 92.35% of net earnings from self-employment. The Social Security portion applies only up to the annual wage base ($184,500 for 2026 and $192,300 for 2027), while the Medicare portion has no limit. One-half of the self-employment tax is deductible in figuring adjusted gross income.
Higher earners may also owe the 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax. The threshold depends on filing status: $250,000 for married couples filing jointly, $125,000 for married individuals filing separately, and $200,000 for all other taxpayers.
Sources: IRS Topic No. 554, Self-Employment Tax; IRS Topic No. 560, Additional Medicare Tax; Social Security Administration: Contribution and Benefit Base
Employment Taxes With the Election
After an S election, an owner who works in the business is a shareholder-employee. An S corporation shareholder-employee who performs services generally must receive reasonable compensation through payroll before nonwage distributions. Social Security and Medicare taxes on those wages total 15.3%: the employee’s 7.65% is withheld from pay, and the corporation pays the other 7.65%.
Profit remaining after wages and other business expenses passes through to the owner’s individual return. Income passed through to an S corporation shareholder is not net earnings from self-employment, so it is not subject to self-employment tax. Income tax still applies to both the wages and the pass-through income, and the overall federal and state income-tax result can vary with the owner’s circumstances.
Sources: IRS: S Corporation Compensation and Medical Insurance Issues; IRS Topic No. 751, Social Security and Medicare Withholding Rates; IRS Publication 560, Retirement Plans for Small Business
A Simplified Illustration
The following simplified illustration compares employment taxes for one business under both approaches. It assumes:
- a single-member LLC owned by one individual who works in the business and is taxed under the default rules (LLCs with more than one member, or with other elections, may be taxed differently);
- $250,000 of profit before any pay to the owner;
- a salary of $120,000 after the election, used for illustration only and not as a recommended salary;
- an owner who files as single and has no other wages;
- the 2027 Social Security wage base of $192,300; and
- employment taxes only, with income taxes not included.
Simplified Illustration: 2027 Employment Taxes on $250,000 of Profit
| Default LLC | With an S Election | |
|---|---|---|
| Earnings taxed | $230,875 | $120,000 salary |
| Social Security | $23,845 | $14,880 |
| Medicare | $6,695 | $3,480 |
| Additional Medicare Tax (single filer) | $278 | $0 |
| Total employment taxes | $30,818 | $18,360 |
| Difference | $12,458 | |
| Assumed added costs | $2,500 | |
| Difference after assumed costs | About $9,960 |
How the figures are calculated: without the election, self-employment tax applies to 92.35% of $250,000 ($230,875), with Social Security at 12.4% up to $192,300, Medicare at 2.9%, and the Additional Medicare Tax at 0.9% above $200,000 for a single filer. With the election, Social Security and Medicare total 15.3% of the $120,000 salary, shared between the owner and the corporation. Assumed added costs include payroll processing, the separate S corporation return, and federal and state unemployment taxes. The $2,500 is an assumption for this illustration, not a quoted or typical cost; actual costs vary.
In this simplified illustration, employment taxes are about $9,960 lower for the year after the assumed costs. This compares employment taxes only. It is not an estimate of total tax savings, and it is not a typical or guaranteed result. A married couple filing jointly would not owe the Additional Medicare Tax at this income level, so the difference would be $278 smaller. Income taxes, the QBI deduction, and state taxes can reduce or offset the difference.
What Can Change the Result
Actual results can vary based on:
- the reasonable compensation the facts support for the owner’s work;
- filing status, and other wages and income;
- deductions, including the corporation’s deduction for the owner’s wages and its share of payroll taxes;
- the qualified business income (QBI) deduction, which can change because reasonable compensation from an S corporation is not qualified business income;
- state and local taxes;
- payroll and compliance costs; and
- other facts and circumstances.
Because the Social Security portion stops at the wage base, the difference also grows more slowly once an owner’s self-employment earnings pass that level.
Sources: IRS: Instructions for Form 8995; IRS Topic No. 554, Self-Employment Tax; Social Security Administration: Contribution and Benefit Base
Any savings in employment taxes generally come from the share of profit that is not paid as wages.
Weigh the Conditions and Costs
Reasonable Compensation
Reasonable compensation is central to the analysis. The salary in the illustration above is not a recommendation for any business; what is reasonable depends on the services the owner actually performs and other facts. Setting compensation artificially low may increase the risk that distributions are reclassified as wages, potentially resulting in additional employment taxes, penalties, and interest.
Keeping a record of how the salary was determined helps support it. When reasonable pay for the owner’s work is close to the business’s total profit, little remains to be distributed, and the election may not reduce employment taxes in a meaningful way.
Source: IRS: S Corporation Compensation and Medical Insurance Issues
What Else Changes
An S election adds ongoing work and costs, and it affects other parts of the owner’s tax picture.
- Payroll. Wages are paid through payroll, with tax deposits, quarterly and annual returns such as Forms 941 and 940, and a Form W-2 for the owner. State withholding and unemployment insurance registrations may also apply. Payroll and its tax deposits must be funded on schedule, so cash flow should be reviewed in advance.
- A separate return. The corporation files Form 1120-S, generally due March 15 for a calendar-year S corporation, and furnishes a Schedule K-1 to each shareholder. State returns may also be required.
- Retirement contributions. For a self-employed owner, plan contributions are figured on net earnings from self-employment, which do not include income passed through to S corporation shareholders. After an S election, contributions that depend on compensation are generally figured on the owner’s wages, so the amount that can be contributed may change.
- Health insurance. Health and accident insurance premiums paid for a shareholder-employee who owns more than 2% of the S corporation are generally reported as wages in box 1 of the shareholder’s Form W-2. When paid under a plan for all employees or a class of employees, they are generally not subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes. The shareholder may be able to deduct them as self-employed health insurance, subject to applicable rules.
- Social Security record. Social Security benefits are generally computed from up to 35 years of a worker’s indexed earnings, so lower wages may mean lower earnings on the owner’s record.
- Bookkeeping. Wages and distributions should be recorded separately and supported by clear records.
Sources: IRS: S Corporations; IRS: Instructions for Form 1120-S; IRS Topic No. 759, Form 940, Federal Unemployment (FUTA) Tax Return; IRS Publication 560, Retirement Plans for Small Business; IRS: One-Participant 401(k) Plans; IRS: S Corporation Compensation and Medical Insurance Issues; Social Security Administration: Benefit Formula
When an S Election May Not Fit
An S election may not be a good fit when:
- profit is modest or varies widely from year to year;
- reasonable pay for the owner’s work is close to the total profit;
- the owner is not ready to run and fund payroll every pay period;
- the ownership does not meet the eligibility requirements; or
- members want to share profit in a way that differs from their ownership percentages.
Timing for a 2027 Election
For an existing calendar-year business, March 15, 2027, is generally the regular deadline to file an S election that takes effect on January 1, 2027. The election may also be filed early, at any time during 2026, to take effect on January 1, 2027, and a new business generally has 2 months and 15 days from the beginning of its first tax year. A business that misses the deadline may qualify for late-election relief under Rev. Proc. 2013-30. Relief is not automatic: the business must be eligible, show reasonable cause for the late filing, and meet the other requirements.
Sources: IRS: Instructions for Form 2553; IRS: Instructions for Form 1120-S
Key Dates for a 2027 S Election
| What | Date or Timing |
|---|---|
| Form 2553 early filing window for a January 1, 2027 effective date | Any time during 2026 |
| Form 2553 regular filing deadline for a January 1, 2027 effective date | March 15, 2027 |
| S election for a new business | Generally, within 2 months and 15 days after its first tax year begins |
| Late-election relief | Generally, within 3 years and 75 days of the intended effective date; not automatic, eligibility and reasonable cause required |
| First Form 1120-S for calendar year 2027 | Generally, March 15, 2028 |
The costs of an S election recur every year, so they belong in the comparison from the start.
LLC vs. S Corp in Virginia, Maryland, and Washington, D.C.
State rules can change the comparison, and they differ across the DMV.
Virginia. S corporations are pass-through entities that generally file Virginia Form 502, and their owners report their shares of income on their own returns. A single-member LLC is not a Form 502 filer, so for its owner an S election generally adds a Virginia return. Wages paid for services performed in Virginia require Virginia income tax withholding, and unemployment insurance generally applies to an S corporation owner’s salary, although sole proprietor and partner compensation is not reportable for unemployment insurance.
Maryland. Maryland sets its own rules. S corporations are among the pass-through entities covered by Maryland’s pass-through entity returns, and the entity generally must pay tax on behalf of nonresident members. An election is also available for the entity to pay tax for all members.
Washington, D.C. The District generally taxes business income at the entity level. S corporations are generally subject to the District’s corporation franchise tax and file Form D-20. Many LLCs and other unincorporated businesses file the unincorporated business franchise tax return (Form D-30), generally once gross income exceeds $12,000. Some are exempt, such as certain professional practices where more than 80% of gross income comes from personal services and capital is not a material income-producing factor. Because both approaches can involve entity-level tax, the federal comparison works differently in the District and should be modeled separately.
When we review entity questions with clients, we look at the federal, state, and local picture together.
Sources: Virginia Tax: Pass-Through Entities; Virginia Tax: Withholding Tax FAQs; Virginia Employment Commission: Employer FAQs; Comptroller of Maryland: Form 510/511D (2026); DC Office of Tax and Revenue: Franchise Tax FAQs; DC Office of Tax and Revenue: 2025 Form D-30 Instructions
Should You Be an LLC or an S Corp? What to Do Before You Decide
- Use your 2026 results to project 2027 profit.
- Confirm how your LLC is classified today and who owns it.
- Estimate a reasonable salary for the work you perform, and document how you arrived at it.
- Compare employment taxes, income tax (including the QBI deduction), and state taxes using your own numbers.
- Price payroll, the federal and state returns, and the added bookkeeping, and confirm that cash flow can support payroll every pay period.
- If the election fits, plan to file Form 2553, with the consent of all required shareholders, for a January 1, 2027 effective date, and set up payroll before the first distribution.
- Review the decision with your accounting or tax professional.
A question we often hear
Is there a profit level where an S election always makes sense?
No. There is no magic profit number at which an S Corp automatically makes sense. The decision should be based on the owner’s and business’s actual numbers, including a reasonable salary for the work performed, other income, state taxes, and the cost of running payroll and a separate return.
Sources
- IRS: Limited Liability Company (LLC)
- IRS: S Corporations
- IRS: Instructions for Form 2553
- IRS: S Corporation Compensation and Medical Insurance Issues
- IRS: Topic No. 554, Self-Employment Tax
- IRS: Topic No. 560, Additional Medicare Tax
- IRS: Topic No. 751, Social Security and Medicare Withholding Rates
- IRS: Topic No. 759, Form 940, Federal Unemployment (FUTA) Tax Return
- IRS: Instructions for Form 1120-S
- IRS: Instructions for Form 8995 (2025)
- IRS: Publication 560, Retirement Plans for Small Business
- IRS: One-Participant 401(k) Plans
- IRS: Tax relief in disaster situations
- Social Security Administration: Contribution and Benefit Base
- Social Security Administration: Benefit Formula
- Virginia Tax: Pass-Through Entities
- Virginia Tax: Withholding Tax FAQs
- Virginia Employment Commission: Employer FAQs
- Comptroller of Maryland: Form 510/511D, Pass-Through Entity Declaration of Estimated Income Tax (2026)
- DC Office of Tax and Revenue: Franchise Tax FAQs
- DC Office of Tax and Revenue: 2025 Form D-30 Instructions
Let’s Talk About Your Business Structure
Every business is different, and the right structure depends on your numbers and goals. If you would like to review whether an S election may fit your plans for 2027, we’re here to help.
Schedule a Free Initial Consultation
M&S Accounting Group | Numbers for a Brighter Tomorrow | msacctgroup.com